Why wasn't Adam Harishon given the Torah?












6















If Adom Harishon was the purpose of the entire creation, why didn't Hashem give him the Torah?



We know that Hashem used the Torah as the blueprint for creation, so it seems strange it was not given to Adam.










share|improve this question

























  • the "Torah" and "giving" must be defined prior to answering this question. I assume you refer to the written scroll of Torah as we have nowadays.

    – Al Berko
    Feb 4 at 9:18
















6















If Adom Harishon was the purpose of the entire creation, why didn't Hashem give him the Torah?



We know that Hashem used the Torah as the blueprint for creation, so it seems strange it was not given to Adam.










share|improve this question

























  • the "Torah" and "giving" must be defined prior to answering this question. I assume you refer to the written scroll of Torah as we have nowadays.

    – Al Berko
    Feb 4 at 9:18














6












6








6








If Adom Harishon was the purpose of the entire creation, why didn't Hashem give him the Torah?



We know that Hashem used the Torah as the blueprint for creation, so it seems strange it was not given to Adam.










share|improve this question
















If Adom Harishon was the purpose of the entire creation, why didn't Hashem give him the Torah?



We know that Hashem used the Torah as the blueprint for creation, so it seems strange it was not given to Adam.







parshanut-torah-comment torah-study adam






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Feb 4 at 15:10









Peter Mortensen

1335




1335










asked Feb 4 at 0:49









ShailahShailah

671




671













  • the "Torah" and "giving" must be defined prior to answering this question. I assume you refer to the written scroll of Torah as we have nowadays.

    – Al Berko
    Feb 4 at 9:18



















  • the "Torah" and "giving" must be defined prior to answering this question. I assume you refer to the written scroll of Torah as we have nowadays.

    – Al Berko
    Feb 4 at 9:18

















the "Torah" and "giving" must be defined prior to answering this question. I assume you refer to the written scroll of Torah as we have nowadays.

– Al Berko
Feb 4 at 9:18





the "Torah" and "giving" must be defined prior to answering this question. I assume you refer to the written scroll of Torah as we have nowadays.

– Al Berko
Feb 4 at 9:18










3 Answers
3






active

oldest

votes


















10














Adam was worthy of having the Torah given through him. Said the Holy One, Blessed is He “ I will give it to him for he is the work of my hands” After he sinned the Holy One, Blessed is He said to him “What Now? I gave you six commandments and you could not uphold them. How can I give you 613? Adam was worthy of begetting the twelve tribes. Said the Holy One Blessed is He “ I gave you two sons, and one rose and slew the other. What will happen if I give you twelve tribes? (Bereishis Rabah 24:5)






share|improve this answer

































    1














    In my understanding, he was given the Torah. However, the Torah stayed oral and abstract and could not be limited to letters as we perceive the Torah after Matan Torah.



    This could be compared to the 4 states of matter, in the beginning it was like fire, not even forming letters, then liquid, forming letters but not words and verses, and finally it was crystallized in the form of words and sentences as we know it.



    Some say (Beis Gnozay, p. Yisro) that the Matan Torah in its literal form was caused by inability to complete the 400 years of slavery and the sin of the Golden calf, otherwise the Torah would stay oral, just the way our forefathers learned it.






    share|improve this answer































      0














      I heard someone mention that since he was created as full adult he could not be given the Torah. Only a child who grows with it can be worthy to accept it. I have not been able to find this said by anyone. Also is there a source for the idea Adom was created as a full grown adult? Is it a machloket?






      share|improve this answer
























      • Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

        – Daniel Ross
        Feb 4 at 22:57



















      3 Answers
      3






      active

      oldest

      votes








      3 Answers
      3






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes









      10














      Adam was worthy of having the Torah given through him. Said the Holy One, Blessed is He “ I will give it to him for he is the work of my hands” After he sinned the Holy One, Blessed is He said to him “What Now? I gave you six commandments and you could not uphold them. How can I give you 613? Adam was worthy of begetting the twelve tribes. Said the Holy One Blessed is He “ I gave you two sons, and one rose and slew the other. What will happen if I give you twelve tribes? (Bereishis Rabah 24:5)






      share|improve this answer






























        10














        Adam was worthy of having the Torah given through him. Said the Holy One, Blessed is He “ I will give it to him for he is the work of my hands” After he sinned the Holy One, Blessed is He said to him “What Now? I gave you six commandments and you could not uphold them. How can I give you 613? Adam was worthy of begetting the twelve tribes. Said the Holy One Blessed is He “ I gave you two sons, and one rose and slew the other. What will happen if I give you twelve tribes? (Bereishis Rabah 24:5)






        share|improve this answer




























          10












          10








          10







          Adam was worthy of having the Torah given through him. Said the Holy One, Blessed is He “ I will give it to him for he is the work of my hands” After he sinned the Holy One, Blessed is He said to him “What Now? I gave you six commandments and you could not uphold them. How can I give you 613? Adam was worthy of begetting the twelve tribes. Said the Holy One Blessed is He “ I gave you two sons, and one rose and slew the other. What will happen if I give you twelve tribes? (Bereishis Rabah 24:5)






          share|improve this answer















          Adam was worthy of having the Torah given through him. Said the Holy One, Blessed is He “ I will give it to him for he is the work of my hands” After he sinned the Holy One, Blessed is He said to him “What Now? I gave you six commandments and you could not uphold them. How can I give you 613? Adam was worthy of begetting the twelve tribes. Said the Holy One Blessed is He “ I gave you two sons, and one rose and slew the other. What will happen if I give you twelve tribes? (Bereishis Rabah 24:5)







          share|improve this answer














          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer








          edited Feb 4 at 7:14









          Kazi bácsi

          2,5291825




          2,5291825










          answered Feb 4 at 1:02









          Daniel RossDaniel Ross

          693111




          693111























              1














              In my understanding, he was given the Torah. However, the Torah stayed oral and abstract and could not be limited to letters as we perceive the Torah after Matan Torah.



              This could be compared to the 4 states of matter, in the beginning it was like fire, not even forming letters, then liquid, forming letters but not words and verses, and finally it was crystallized in the form of words and sentences as we know it.



              Some say (Beis Gnozay, p. Yisro) that the Matan Torah in its literal form was caused by inability to complete the 400 years of slavery and the sin of the Golden calf, otherwise the Torah would stay oral, just the way our forefathers learned it.






              share|improve this answer




























                1














                In my understanding, he was given the Torah. However, the Torah stayed oral and abstract and could not be limited to letters as we perceive the Torah after Matan Torah.



                This could be compared to the 4 states of matter, in the beginning it was like fire, not even forming letters, then liquid, forming letters but not words and verses, and finally it was crystallized in the form of words and sentences as we know it.



                Some say (Beis Gnozay, p. Yisro) that the Matan Torah in its literal form was caused by inability to complete the 400 years of slavery and the sin of the Golden calf, otherwise the Torah would stay oral, just the way our forefathers learned it.






                share|improve this answer


























                  1












                  1








                  1







                  In my understanding, he was given the Torah. However, the Torah stayed oral and abstract and could not be limited to letters as we perceive the Torah after Matan Torah.



                  This could be compared to the 4 states of matter, in the beginning it was like fire, not even forming letters, then liquid, forming letters but not words and verses, and finally it was crystallized in the form of words and sentences as we know it.



                  Some say (Beis Gnozay, p. Yisro) that the Matan Torah in its literal form was caused by inability to complete the 400 years of slavery and the sin of the Golden calf, otherwise the Torah would stay oral, just the way our forefathers learned it.






                  share|improve this answer













                  In my understanding, he was given the Torah. However, the Torah stayed oral and abstract and could not be limited to letters as we perceive the Torah after Matan Torah.



                  This could be compared to the 4 states of matter, in the beginning it was like fire, not even forming letters, then liquid, forming letters but not words and verses, and finally it was crystallized in the form of words and sentences as we know it.



                  Some say (Beis Gnozay, p. Yisro) that the Matan Torah in its literal form was caused by inability to complete the 400 years of slavery and the sin of the Golden calf, otherwise the Torah would stay oral, just the way our forefathers learned it.







                  share|improve this answer












                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer










                  answered Feb 4 at 7:54









                  Al BerkoAl Berko

                  5,304526




                  5,304526























                      0














                      I heard someone mention that since he was created as full adult he could not be given the Torah. Only a child who grows with it can be worthy to accept it. I have not been able to find this said by anyone. Also is there a source for the idea Adom was created as a full grown adult? Is it a machloket?






                      share|improve this answer
























                      • Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

                        – Daniel Ross
                        Feb 4 at 22:57
















                      0














                      I heard someone mention that since he was created as full adult he could not be given the Torah. Only a child who grows with it can be worthy to accept it. I have not been able to find this said by anyone. Also is there a source for the idea Adom was created as a full grown adult? Is it a machloket?






                      share|improve this answer
























                      • Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

                        – Daniel Ross
                        Feb 4 at 22:57














                      0












                      0








                      0







                      I heard someone mention that since he was created as full adult he could not be given the Torah. Only a child who grows with it can be worthy to accept it. I have not been able to find this said by anyone. Also is there a source for the idea Adom was created as a full grown adult? Is it a machloket?






                      share|improve this answer













                      I heard someone mention that since he was created as full adult he could not be given the Torah. Only a child who grows with it can be worthy to accept it. I have not been able to find this said by anyone. Also is there a source for the idea Adom was created as a full grown adult? Is it a machloket?







                      share|improve this answer












                      share|improve this answer



                      share|improve this answer










                      answered Feb 4 at 20:34









                      ShailahShailah

                      671




                      671













                      • Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

                        – Daniel Ross
                        Feb 4 at 22:57



















                      • Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

                        – Daniel Ross
                        Feb 4 at 22:57

















                      Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

                      – Daniel Ross
                      Feb 4 at 22:57





                      Regarding your 2nd point (age) see Bereishis Rabah 14:7

                      – Daniel Ross
                      Feb 4 at 22:57



                      Popular posts from this blog

                      How to reconfigure Docker Trusted Registry 2.x.x to use CEPH FS mount instead of NFS and other traditional...

                      is 'sed' thread safe

                      How to make a Squid Proxy server?